The other night at dinner with good friends, the subject of religion versus spirituality came up.
In recent years, I have filled a file with notes and papers on this subject; but I have only just recently identified what I judge the clearest and best description of the difference between them.
It is found in Chapter Two of Joan Chittister's book, Called to Question (p.19):
Religion is about what we believe and why we believe it. It is about the tradition, the institution, the system. Constructed over centuries--more than five thousand years ago for Hinduism, the first formal religion--religion draws for the world a portrait of creation and relationships. It gives us creeds and dogmas and definitions of God. It gathers us in worship and reminds us of a world to come.
Spirituality is about the hunger in the human heart. It seeks not only a way to exist, but a reason to exist that is beyond the biological or the institutional or even the traditional. It lifts religion up from the level of the theoretical or the mechanical to the personal. It seeks to make real the things of the spirit. It transcends rules and rituals to a concentration on meaning. It pursues in depth the mystical dimensions of life that religion purports to promote.
Sister Joan then ends the chapter on page 24 with this:
Religion, the finger pointing at the moon, is not the moon. Simply keeping the rules, accepting the conventions, and loving the pomp that comes with religion will not get us there. For that we need a spirituality of search.
Saturday, August 18, 2012
Saturday, August 11, 2012
Definitions of Spirituality
Spirituality means different things to different people.
Here are some descriptions that I find meaningful:
"...spirituality is not a separate part of life but rather the deepest dimension and ground of all life."
[from the Institute of Spiritual Companionship]
"Spirituality has many definitions but at its core spirituality helps to give our life context. It's not necessarily connected to a specific belief system or even religious worship. Instead, it arises from your connection with yourself and with others, the development of your personal value system, and your search for meaning in life...Spirituality is different for everyone."
[from Mayo Clinic's website on "Stress Management"]
"The essence of the spiritual life is to stay connected to the sacred place within that holds the memory of wholeness, peace and balance for us, no matter how far our hearts or minds may be pulled."
[Jonathan H. Ellerby]
To me, my spirituality is what motivates me, deep down, to get out of bed in the morning and face the adventure of a new day; and then my spirituality helps me cope with whatever joys and sorrows may come.
Here are some descriptions that I find meaningful:
"...spirituality is not a separate part of life but rather the deepest dimension and ground of all life."
[from the Institute of Spiritual Companionship]
"Spirituality has many definitions but at its core spirituality helps to give our life context. It's not necessarily connected to a specific belief system or even religious worship. Instead, it arises from your connection with yourself and with others, the development of your personal value system, and your search for meaning in life...Spirituality is different for everyone."
[from Mayo Clinic's website on "Stress Management"]
"The essence of the spiritual life is to stay connected to the sacred place within that holds the memory of wholeness, peace and balance for us, no matter how far our hearts or minds may be pulled."
[Jonathan H. Ellerby]
To me, my spirituality is what motivates me, deep down, to get out of bed in the morning and face the adventure of a new day; and then my spirituality helps me cope with whatever joys and sorrows may come.
Monday, August 6, 2012
Questions...Questions...Questions
My fundamentalist Baptist childhood indoctrinated me with the notion that it was wrong to ask questions.
As I recall, we were taught to question anything in the Bible was the work of "Satan."
Perhaps it is a sign that I am 'full of the devil', but I have never been free of questions.
Case in point--one of my earliest sermons (late'60's) was entitled:
JESUS IS THE ANSWER...WHAT IS THE QUESTION?
This morning Janice (my spiritual coach, and wife) shared a wonderful paragraph from the book entitled Called to Question by Sister Joan Chittister:
IF THERE IS ONE THING THAT WE HAVE ALL BEEN TAUGHT to fear, it is surely questions.
There are some things, we learn early, that are never to be challenged. They simply are. They are absolute. They come out of a fountain of eternal truth. And they are true because someone else said they are true. So we live with someone else's answers for a long time. Until the answers run dry. I know that because I myself have been caught in the desert of doubt and found the answers to be worse than the questions could ever be. [p. 2]
I have been intrigued with the current supporters of the Chick-fil-A opposition to gay marriage, based on their belief that the Bible (and God) decrees that marriage is between one man and one woman.
I am currently reading The Daily Message / Through the Bible in One Year by Eugene H. Peterson.
Now over half-way through, I have refreshed my memory of enough of the Old Testament to question whether the Bible has any coherent and consistent view of marriage. As Rabbi Rami Shapiro recently pointed out in his blog, Beyond Religion with Rabbi Rami (see "Chick-Lit" posted 8/01/12), marriage in the OT included polygamy. [Quiz: Name the one wife of Jacob? Was it Rachel or Leah? Can you say both! Check out King David and Solomon!] And my current daily readings in I Corinthians make it clear that St. Paul had a very dim view of marriage, i.e. "stay single!"
My mother in law had a friend who stated her understanding of the Biblical view of marriage:
"Once you're married you're stuck!"
Unfortunately, the fact is that many of the marriage ceremonies I have performed (my first was in 1972) later ended in divorce. I don't have the answer to what makes one marriage last and another fail, but I'm very grateful that Janice has chosen to stay with me for 40 years come the 20th of this month!
As I recall, we were taught to question anything in the Bible was the work of "Satan."
Perhaps it is a sign that I am 'full of the devil', but I have never been free of questions.
Case in point--one of my earliest sermons (late'60's) was entitled:
JESUS IS THE ANSWER...WHAT IS THE QUESTION?
This morning Janice (my spiritual coach, and wife) shared a wonderful paragraph from the book entitled Called to Question by Sister Joan Chittister:
IF THERE IS ONE THING THAT WE HAVE ALL BEEN TAUGHT to fear, it is surely questions.
There are some things, we learn early, that are never to be challenged. They simply are. They are absolute. They come out of a fountain of eternal truth. And they are true because someone else said they are true. So we live with someone else's answers for a long time. Until the answers run dry. I know that because I myself have been caught in the desert of doubt and found the answers to be worse than the questions could ever be. [p. 2]
I have been intrigued with the current supporters of the Chick-fil-A opposition to gay marriage, based on their belief that the Bible (and God) decrees that marriage is between one man and one woman.
I am currently reading The Daily Message / Through the Bible in One Year by Eugene H. Peterson.
Now over half-way through, I have refreshed my memory of enough of the Old Testament to question whether the Bible has any coherent and consistent view of marriage. As Rabbi Rami Shapiro recently pointed out in his blog, Beyond Religion with Rabbi Rami (see "Chick-Lit" posted 8/01/12), marriage in the OT included polygamy. [Quiz: Name the one wife of Jacob? Was it Rachel or Leah? Can you say both! Check out King David and Solomon!] And my current daily readings in I Corinthians make it clear that St. Paul had a very dim view of marriage, i.e. "stay single!"
My mother in law had a friend who stated her understanding of the Biblical view of marriage:
"Once you're married you're stuck!"
Unfortunately, the fact is that many of the marriage ceremonies I have performed (my first was in 1972) later ended in divorce. I don't have the answer to what makes one marriage last and another fail, but I'm very grateful that Janice has chosen to stay with me for 40 years come the 20th of this month!
Friday, June 1, 2012
The Blind Men and the Elephant
Can you describe a sunset?
Neither can I, as words fail.
The same is true for the divine, yet we try to describe God, or at least our experience of what we take to be the divine.
Indeed, you may feel that you have experienced God, and I may feel likewise...but the description of my experience does not invalidate your description, or vice versa. Both or neither may be accurate, but we are simply trying to describe a subjective experience...so why argue or debate? We do so when we try to make the subjective into the objective, and turn spirituality into religion (the inward into the outward.)
Consider "The Parable of the Blind Men and the Elephant" by John Godfrey Saxe (1816-1887):
It was six men of Indostan
to learning much inclined,
Who went to see the Elephant
(Though all of them were blind),
That each by observation
Might satisfy his mind.
The first approached the Elephant,
And happened to fall
Against his broad and sturdy side,
At once began to bawl:
God bless me! but the Elephant
Is very like a wall!"
The second, feeling of the tusk
Cried: "Ho what have we here
So very round and smooth and sharp?
To me 'tis very clear
This wonder of and Elephant
Is very like a spear!"
The Third approached the animal
And happening to take
The squirming trunk within his hands
Thus boldly up he spake.
"I see." quoth he, "the Elephant
Is very like a snake!"
The Fourth reached out an eager hand
And felt about the knee.
"What most this wonderful beast is like
Is very plain." quoth he;
" 'Tis clear enough the Elephant
Is very like a tree!"
The Fifth, who chanced to touch the ear,
Said, "E'en the blindest man
Can tell what this resembles most;
Deny the fact who can
This marvel of an Elephant
Is very like a fan!"
The sixth no sooner had begun
About the beast to grope
Than, seizing on the swinging tail
That fell within his scope.
"I see," quoth he, "the Elephant
Is very like a rope!"
And so these men of Indostan
Disputed loud and long,
Each in his own opinion
Exceeding still and strong,
Though each was part;y in the right,
They all were in the wrong!
So oft in theologic wars
The disputants, I ween
Rail on in utter ignorance
Of what each other mean
And prat about an Elephant
Not one of them has seen!
Neither can I, as words fail.
The same is true for the divine, yet we try to describe God, or at least our experience of what we take to be the divine.
Indeed, you may feel that you have experienced God, and I may feel likewise...but the description of my experience does not invalidate your description, or vice versa. Both or neither may be accurate, but we are simply trying to describe a subjective experience...so why argue or debate? We do so when we try to make the subjective into the objective, and turn spirituality into religion (the inward into the outward.)
Consider "The Parable of the Blind Men and the Elephant" by John Godfrey Saxe (1816-1887):
It was six men of Indostan
to learning much inclined,
Who went to see the Elephant
(Though all of them were blind),
That each by observation
Might satisfy his mind.
The first approached the Elephant,
And happened to fall
Against his broad and sturdy side,
At once began to bawl:
God bless me! but the Elephant
Is very like a wall!"
The second, feeling of the tusk
Cried: "Ho what have we here
So very round and smooth and sharp?
To me 'tis very clear
This wonder of and Elephant
Is very like a spear!"
The Third approached the animal
And happening to take
The squirming trunk within his hands
Thus boldly up he spake.
"I see." quoth he, "the Elephant
Is very like a snake!"
The Fourth reached out an eager hand
And felt about the knee.
"What most this wonderful beast is like
Is very plain." quoth he;
" 'Tis clear enough the Elephant
Is very like a tree!"
The Fifth, who chanced to touch the ear,
Said, "E'en the blindest man
Can tell what this resembles most;
Deny the fact who can
This marvel of an Elephant
Is very like a fan!"
The sixth no sooner had begun
About the beast to grope
Than, seizing on the swinging tail
That fell within his scope.
"I see," quoth he, "the Elephant
Is very like a rope!"
And so these men of Indostan
Disputed loud and long,
Each in his own opinion
Exceeding still and strong,
Though each was part;y in the right,
They all were in the wrong!
So oft in theologic wars
The disputants, I ween
Rail on in utter ignorance
Of what each other mean
And prat about an Elephant
Not one of them has seen!
Thursday, March 22, 2012
RELIGIONS ARE CONTAINERS FOR GOD
I find asking the question, "What is God?", is my attempt to contain G-D...to make the Mystery more manageable.
And my answers to the question are best revealed by the followiing story I once used in a sermon:
It was 6-year old Billy's first visit to the ocean, and he had planned his mission for 'Show and Tell' before he got there.
Wading out into the surf, he carried an empty mayonaise jar which he dipped into the water.
The jar was filled almost instantaneously and he quickly put the lid on the jar.
When he went back to school, he carried his jar with him.
When it was his turn for 'Show and Tell', he proudly held up his jar and announced:
"THIS IS THE OCEAN! I HAVE THE OCEAN!"
Billy's enthusiasm and innocence is sweet...but his jar no more contained the ocean than we can contain G-D.
It seems clear to me that the word "God" means different things to different people.
So do any of us have the right to tell others that we are right and they are wrong?
How do we know? And to quote the Bible or any religious scripture is to beg the question.
Many consider Hinduism to promote polytheism because Hindus worship hundreds of gods.
But the deeper Hindu understanding according to Swami Satchidananda is that each god represents an aspect of the human experience of the divine.
Actually, we all see and experience the Mystery differently...and some not at all.
Sensory psychologists inform us that we all tend to see what we are trained or choose to look at.
We "see" from different perspectives and seldom, if ever, see the whole picture.
The Apostle Paul recognized this when he said "Now I see through a glass darkly." (I Cor. 13:12)
The Bible itself points to the impenetrable mystery of the divine.
The Psalmist has God saying "My thoughts are above your thoughts..." and Moses asks God:
"What is your name?" and is given the inscrutable Zen-type answer:
"I AM THAT I AM."
Most religions seek to answer the question "What is God?" by promoting a particular belief system based on certain experiences. But this is where the analogy of fleas arguing about who owns the dog applies, for each flea has an "experience" when they take a bite of the dog. But that bite hardly provides an experience or knowledge of the whole dog, much less ownership.
So I am not trying to pursue a religion, but simply trying to understand and develop my own feelings and experiences of G-D... my own PATCHWORK QUILT SPIRITUALITY.
And my answers to the question are best revealed by the followiing story I once used in a sermon:
It was 6-year old Billy's first visit to the ocean, and he had planned his mission for 'Show and Tell' before he got there.
Wading out into the surf, he carried an empty mayonaise jar which he dipped into the water.
The jar was filled almost instantaneously and he quickly put the lid on the jar.
When he went back to school, he carried his jar with him.
When it was his turn for 'Show and Tell', he proudly held up his jar and announced:
"THIS IS THE OCEAN! I HAVE THE OCEAN!"
Billy's enthusiasm and innocence is sweet...but his jar no more contained the ocean than we can contain G-D.
It seems clear to me that the word "God" means different things to different people.
So do any of us have the right to tell others that we are right and they are wrong?
How do we know? And to quote the Bible or any religious scripture is to beg the question.
Many consider Hinduism to promote polytheism because Hindus worship hundreds of gods.
But the deeper Hindu understanding according to Swami Satchidananda is that each god represents an aspect of the human experience of the divine.
Actually, we all see and experience the Mystery differently...and some not at all.
Sensory psychologists inform us that we all tend to see what we are trained or choose to look at.
We "see" from different perspectives and seldom, if ever, see the whole picture.
The Apostle Paul recognized this when he said "Now I see through a glass darkly." (I Cor. 13:12)
The Bible itself points to the impenetrable mystery of the divine.
The Psalmist has God saying "My thoughts are above your thoughts..." and Moses asks God:
"What is your name?" and is given the inscrutable Zen-type answer:
"I AM THAT I AM."
Most religions seek to answer the question "What is God?" by promoting a particular belief system based on certain experiences. But this is where the analogy of fleas arguing about who owns the dog applies, for each flea has an "experience" when they take a bite of the dog. But that bite hardly provides an experience or knowledge of the whole dog, much less ownership.
So I am not trying to pursue a religion, but simply trying to understand and develop my own feelings and experiences of G-D... my own PATCHWORK QUILT SPIRITUALITY.
Saturday, March 10, 2012
What is God?
What is God? Ask 10 people and get 10 different answers. In fact, if you go to the evangelical website god.com you will see the following statement:
"There are over six billion people in this world and each person has his or her own thoughts about God."
Many will say that they believe in God...but actually, the word "God" means different things to different people. That's why philospher/theologian Sam Keen proposed a moratorium on the use of the word a few years ago...and suggested some possible new names:
The Quantum Leaper...The Beyond Within...The Cosmic DNA...The Creating...The Original One...The Alpha and Omega Helix...The Ground and Void of Being...Etc., etc., etc. without End.
The old preacher in the "Kudzu" cartoon series of Doug Marlette (now deceased) offers some friendly advice. Rev. Will B. Dunn is working on his "Tell It to the Preacher" advice column for the newspaper and is reading the following letter:
Dear Preacher,
Do you address the Supreme Being as the "Eternal Thou" like Buber...or do you prefer Tillich's "Ground of Being" or his "Ultimate Concern?"
...or do you use Hegel's "Absolute Spirit" or Rudolph Otto's "Mysterium Tremendum?"
(Sincerely ) Seeker
Then Rev. Will B. Dunn (smiling) types his answer:
Dear Seeker,
You say it Yahweh and I'll say it mine.
[Amen--Ty]
"There are over six billion people in this world and each person has his or her own thoughts about God."
Many will say that they believe in God...but actually, the word "God" means different things to different people. That's why philospher/theologian Sam Keen proposed a moratorium on the use of the word a few years ago...and suggested some possible new names:
The Quantum Leaper...The Beyond Within...The Cosmic DNA...The Creating...The Original One...The Alpha and Omega Helix...The Ground and Void of Being...Etc., etc., etc. without End.
The old preacher in the "Kudzu" cartoon series of Doug Marlette (now deceased) offers some friendly advice. Rev. Will B. Dunn is working on his "Tell It to the Preacher" advice column for the newspaper and is reading the following letter:
Dear Preacher,
Do you address the Supreme Being as the "Eternal Thou" like Buber...or do you prefer Tillich's "Ground of Being" or his "Ultimate Concern?"
...or do you use Hegel's "Absolute Spirit" or Rudolph Otto's "Mysterium Tremendum?"
(Sincerely ) Seeker
Then Rev. Will B. Dunn (smiling) types his answer:
Dear Seeker,
You say it Yahweh and I'll say it mine.
[Amen--Ty]
Saturday, March 3, 2012
God Talk
"Once upon a time, God lived at the North Pole."
So wrote theologian Robert McAfee Brown in his book, The Gospel According to St. Hereticus.
As a Baby Boomer growing up in the '50's, my image of God as an old, white-haired man sitting on a throne was not unlike the Santa Claus that I loved to visit at the Fowler's Department Store in Binghamton, New York. (I have a wonderful old photo, but I don't know how to upload it!)
Years later, I was still grappling with that image when I entered the seminary in the late 60's and heard the following joke:
"Have you heard about GOD?...She's Black!"
When it comes to human attempts to define or characterize God, we do well to confess that all our efforts are inadequate. Indeed, even that statement "I believe in God" means different things to different people. I recall a story about a college chaplain who was confronted by an angry student, protesting that he did not believe in God. The chaplain simply responded: "Tell me about this God that you do not believe in--maybe I don't believe in that God either."
An old Calvin and Hobbes cartoon makes a similar point. They are sitting on a hill, and Hobbes asks,
"Do you think there is a God?"
Calvin pauses, and then answers:
"I do believe there is Someone who is out to get me."
If we are honest, we must admit that even the Holy Bible leaves us with questions. One of my favorite cartoons puts it simply, as one angel in heaven asks another angel:
"Is he the God of the Old or the New Testament this morning?"
Maybe "She" is both and neither!?!
Ty
So wrote theologian Robert McAfee Brown in his book, The Gospel According to St. Hereticus.
As a Baby Boomer growing up in the '50's, my image of God as an old, white-haired man sitting on a throne was not unlike the Santa Claus that I loved to visit at the Fowler's Department Store in Binghamton, New York. (I have a wonderful old photo, but I don't know how to upload it!)
Years later, I was still grappling with that image when I entered the seminary in the late 60's and heard the following joke:
"Have you heard about GOD?...She's Black!"
When it comes to human attempts to define or characterize God, we do well to confess that all our efforts are inadequate. Indeed, even that statement "I believe in God" means different things to different people. I recall a story about a college chaplain who was confronted by an angry student, protesting that he did not believe in God. The chaplain simply responded: "Tell me about this God that you do not believe in--maybe I don't believe in that God either."
An old Calvin and Hobbes cartoon makes a similar point. They are sitting on a hill, and Hobbes asks,
"Do you think there is a God?"
Calvin pauses, and then answers:
"I do believe there is Someone who is out to get me."
If we are honest, we must admit that even the Holy Bible leaves us with questions. One of my favorite cartoons puts it simply, as one angel in heaven asks another angel:
"Is he the God of the Old or the New Testament this morning?"
Maybe "She" is both and neither!?!
Ty
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)