When I was in seminary over 40 years ago, I studied enough systematic theology to realize that I would never be a theologian.
Some years later I learned that Sam Keen, who had been a seminary professor early in his career, chose not to pursue theology when his first sabbatical came up. He knew that to be regarded as a theologian, he needed to study in Germany. But he chose, instead, to go to Esalen...probably another reason I respect his free spirit.
At any rate, I recently came across one of his talks on You Tube in which he shares the following description:
"A theologian, or religious person, is like a blind person,
in a dark room,
looking for a black cat...
that isn't there...and finding."
Like all analogies, this one has its problems. But it reminds me that all discussions of spirituality need to begin with humility.
In that same talk, Sam also disparages those who would claim to be spiritual but not religious.
However, the SBNR concept still appeals to me:
I'm not very spiritual, but I want to be more congruent, grounded and centered;
I have no desire to be religious.
Saturday, June 22, 2013
Thursday, June 20, 2013
Sittin' and Goin' Nowhere
It's been a good while since I posted anything.
I feel like I've been sitting, going nowhere.
I could blame my malaise on battle fatigue, coping with my only son who struggles with Asperger's and teenage hormones. But my dark night of the soul goes deeper.
Living in Raleigh and seeing all the self-absorbed churches seeking new members is depressing. For example, there are 11 Southern Baptist Churches within a 5-mile radius of where I am sitting.
I can relate to Robert Redford's character in the movie, "An Unfinished Life."
After his granddaughter is rude to the visiting sheriff, he makes it clear that she is to be respectful to anyone that comes to his door...unless it is someone trying to "sell their angle on God...there's no excuse for that s*#t."
Of course, I'm rather stuck with self-absorption myself, and the "world seems too much with us."
Sometimes, perhaps it's good enough just to make it through the day.
Recently I heard a country song that pretty much describes how I've been feeling.
It's sung by Andie MacDowell during John Travolta's movie "Michael" with these lyrics:
I'm sittin' on the side of the road
in the middle of nowhere
I don't know where I'm goin'
But I hope I know it when I get there
Meanwhile, I hear the question of childhood:
Are we there yet?
I feel like I've been sitting, going nowhere.
I could blame my malaise on battle fatigue, coping with my only son who struggles with Asperger's and teenage hormones. But my dark night of the soul goes deeper.
Living in Raleigh and seeing all the self-absorbed churches seeking new members is depressing. For example, there are 11 Southern Baptist Churches within a 5-mile radius of where I am sitting.
I can relate to Robert Redford's character in the movie, "An Unfinished Life."
After his granddaughter is rude to the visiting sheriff, he makes it clear that she is to be respectful to anyone that comes to his door...unless it is someone trying to "sell their angle on God...there's no excuse for that s*#t."
Of course, I'm rather stuck with self-absorption myself, and the "world seems too much with us."
Sometimes, perhaps it's good enough just to make it through the day.
Recently I heard a country song that pretty much describes how I've been feeling.
It's sung by Andie MacDowell during John Travolta's movie "Michael" with these lyrics:
I'm sittin' on the side of the road
in the middle of nowhere
I don't know where I'm goin'
But I hope I know it when I get there
Meanwhile, I hear the question of childhood:
Are we there yet?
Tuesday, March 12, 2013
The Vatican is Blowing Smoke
The news networks are all focused on the Vatican today as they await the election of a new pope.
The waiting is focused on watching the specially installed chimney to see a white puff of smoke--the signal that a new pope has been elected.
I'm sure this ancient practice is an honored tradition, but it seems more than an anachronism in light of today's instant communications. (How many of the cardinals tweet?)
However, as an ex-Baptist who has always rejected the concept of the papacy in the first place, I am struck with the similarities between the college of cardinals process and our American political conventions.
At any rate, what amazes me the most is the unintended symbolism of the smoke.
Whoever is elected, the end result comes down to blowing smoke.
Any religion, whenever it seeks to step beyond its humanity and claim infallibility or other divine authority, is blowing smoke.
The waiting is focused on watching the specially installed chimney to see a white puff of smoke--the signal that a new pope has been elected.
I'm sure this ancient practice is an honored tradition, but it seems more than an anachronism in light of today's instant communications. (How many of the cardinals tweet?)
However, as an ex-Baptist who has always rejected the concept of the papacy in the first place, I am struck with the similarities between the college of cardinals process and our American political conventions.
At any rate, what amazes me the most is the unintended symbolism of the smoke.
Whoever is elected, the end result comes down to blowing smoke.
Any religion, whenever it seeks to step beyond its humanity and claim infallibility or other divine authority, is blowing smoke.
Thursday, January 3, 2013
Jesus Will Return and Set Everything Right
My blog has been empty for several months...for several reasons.
First, I have felt exhausted.
Coping with an Asperger's teenager has been an everyday struggle just to survive and for us to make it through the day.
Second, my faith is hanging by threads.
This dark night of the soul really sucks.
Finally, the horror of Newtown...words cannot convey...
Meanwhile, I have felt guilty, as the end of 2012 has come and 2013 begun...with me at age 65 and no words of wisdom to share! Does the ego ever give up??
Whatever...I must share that this morning I read the following Advent Opinion on the Religious Herald website's Perspective section from Rev. Daniel E. Glaze (Pastor, First Baptist Church, Ahoskie, NC and posted 12/18/12 after the Newtown massacre):
"Joy comes from knowing that evil will not prevail for long. One day Jesus will return and set everything right."
Aha!! There is my problem. I want to believe that; I used to believe that; but I don't believe it any more!
Having just read the Bible through in 2012 with Eugene Peterson's The Message version, I have to conclude that Judaism was correct in rejecting Jesus as the Messiah: he did not fulfill the expectations described in the Hebrew scriptures. And the Christian scriptures pointing to a "Second Coming" of the Christ (Messiah) are attempts to offer hope and explain why Jesus did not fulfill the work of the Messiah the first time. Moreover,
Paul was clearly looking for Jesus to return any day, and John's Revelation was written to encourage those early Christians to hang in there TIL JESUS COMES! But for me, reading Revelation in The Message at the end of 2012 was just disgusting!!
So I have ended 2012 with no great wisdom, and the best I can do as I enter this new year is to raise questions:
How long will evil prevail?
What if the calvary (Jesus) is not coming?
Can everything be set right? What does that mean? How can Newtown be "set right?"
If it is to be, is it up to me?
[G-d help us!]
Meanwhile, there is still a part of me that believes "it is better to light a candle than to curse the darkness."
(I just hope the flame from that candle does not burn out my last thread of faith!)
First, I have felt exhausted.
Coping with an Asperger's teenager has been an everyday struggle just to survive and for us to make it through the day.
Second, my faith is hanging by threads.
This dark night of the soul really sucks.
Finally, the horror of Newtown...words cannot convey...
Meanwhile, I have felt guilty, as the end of 2012 has come and 2013 begun...with me at age 65 and no words of wisdom to share! Does the ego ever give up??
Whatever...I must share that this morning I read the following Advent Opinion on the Religious Herald website's Perspective section from Rev. Daniel E. Glaze (Pastor, First Baptist Church, Ahoskie, NC and posted 12/18/12 after the Newtown massacre):
"Joy comes from knowing that evil will not prevail for long. One day Jesus will return and set everything right."
Aha!! There is my problem. I want to believe that; I used to believe that; but I don't believe it any more!
Having just read the Bible through in 2012 with Eugene Peterson's The Message version, I have to conclude that Judaism was correct in rejecting Jesus as the Messiah: he did not fulfill the expectations described in the Hebrew scriptures. And the Christian scriptures pointing to a "Second Coming" of the Christ (Messiah) are attempts to offer hope and explain why Jesus did not fulfill the work of the Messiah the first time. Moreover,
Paul was clearly looking for Jesus to return any day, and John's Revelation was written to encourage those early Christians to hang in there TIL JESUS COMES! But for me, reading Revelation in The Message at the end of 2012 was just disgusting!!
So I have ended 2012 with no great wisdom, and the best I can do as I enter this new year is to raise questions:
How long will evil prevail?
What if the calvary (Jesus) is not coming?
Can everything be set right? What does that mean? How can Newtown be "set right?"
If it is to be, is it up to me?
[G-d help us!]
Meanwhile, there is still a part of me that believes "it is better to light a candle than to curse the darkness."
(I just hope the flame from that candle does not burn out my last thread of faith!)
Thursday, October 25, 2012
Quotes to Ponder
This quote was on my page-a-day calendar recently:
"As long as you derive inner help and comfort from anything...keep it." --Mahatma Ghandhi
That quote best describes the reason I chose the title "Patchwork Quilt Spirituality."
Sometimes our spirituality comes down to what helps us make it through the day.
But what worked yesterday, sometimes does not work for today.
Then I found the following quote in an e-newsletter a few days ago:
"When we consider yesterday's answers more important than today's questions,
we fail both the past and the future." --Sister Joan Chittister
When Jesus told Nicodemus, "You must be born again!" I believe he meant daily.
As I have moved through life's joys and sorrows, I have often found yesterday's spirituality insufficient for today's struggles. So I "patch" yesterday's weak spot and try to move on...my "faith" evolving as I go.
To quote the Apostle Paul:
"When I was a child, I spoke as a child, I understood as a child, I thought as a child:
but when I became a man, I put away childish things...now I know in part" -- I Corinthians 13
"As long as you derive inner help and comfort from anything...keep it." --Mahatma Ghandhi
That quote best describes the reason I chose the title "Patchwork Quilt Spirituality."
Sometimes our spirituality comes down to what helps us make it through the day.
But what worked yesterday, sometimes does not work for today.
Then I found the following quote in an e-newsletter a few days ago:
"When we consider yesterday's answers more important than today's questions,
we fail both the past and the future." --Sister Joan Chittister
When Jesus told Nicodemus, "You must be born again!" I believe he meant daily.
As I have moved through life's joys and sorrows, I have often found yesterday's spirituality insufficient for today's struggles. So I "patch" yesterday's weak spot and try to move on...my "faith" evolving as I go.
To quote the Apostle Paul:
"When I was a child, I spoke as a child, I understood as a child, I thought as a child:
but when I became a man, I put away childish things...now I know in part" -- I Corinthians 13
Rape and God's Will
"Rape and the Will of God" was the title of yesterday's (10/24/12) blog by my favorite blogger, Rami Shapiro (rabbirami.blogspot.com) as he commented on Indiana Senate candidate Richard Mourdock's statement that if a rape victim became pregnant, "it is something that God intended."
Despite the outcry from all sides over Mourdock's remarks, Rami points our that if you believe (as many Americans do) that God "runs the universe," this is the logical conclusion: if God intended the pregnancy, then God intended the rape.
When I was in seminary, this kind of discussion fell under the rubric of "Theodicy"--the theological enterprise that seeks to address the "Problem of Evil." Simply stated, how can an all-powerful and all-loving God allow evil to exist? Either God has the power to to eliminate evil and chooses not to do so (where is the love?) or God does not have the power to eradicate evil.
During my pastoral days, the best discussion I came across was found in a little book by the great pastor/theologian Leslie Weatherhead entitled The Will of God. He sees God's will in 3 phases: from the beginning, God had an Intentional Will; but because Humans had free will and 'sinned', God developed a
Circumstantial Will; yet God would prevail in the end with God's Ultimate Will. This model was helpful in showing the complexity in the use of the term "God's Will," but it does not solve the problem of evil.
More recently, the esteemed New Testament scholar, Bart Erhman, and professor of religion at the University of North Carolina, published a book entitled God's Problem. I have not yet read the book, which discusses the problem why an all-powerful God allows human suffering. It is my understanding that after dealing with the contradictory biblical explanations, he arrives at atheism, which is, as Rami points out, one possible logical conclusion to the problem of evil.
In 1949, my sister Betsy was born with cystic fibrosis, and died in 1951 when I was 4 years old, The 'theology' of my parents' fundamentalist Baptist church, simply labelled her life and death as "God's will," and I was "comforted" with the pronouncement that she was "too good for this world!" and that Jesus took her to be in heaven. Years later, I realized that even at age 4, I was able to question this (to myself) and come to the conclusion that I was bad enough to stay around. I guess this was my introduction to what psychologists call cognitive dissonance. I want to believe that there is a cosmic life force and energy that is Light and Love, and that the "Holy Mystery" is stronger than evil. But so often it seems that evil is winning.
Despite the outcry from all sides over Mourdock's remarks, Rami points our that if you believe (as many Americans do) that God "runs the universe," this is the logical conclusion: if God intended the pregnancy, then God intended the rape.
When I was in seminary, this kind of discussion fell under the rubric of "Theodicy"--the theological enterprise that seeks to address the "Problem of Evil." Simply stated, how can an all-powerful and all-loving God allow evil to exist? Either God has the power to to eliminate evil and chooses not to do so (where is the love?) or God does not have the power to eradicate evil.
During my pastoral days, the best discussion I came across was found in a little book by the great pastor/theologian Leslie Weatherhead entitled The Will of God. He sees God's will in 3 phases: from the beginning, God had an Intentional Will; but because Humans had free will and 'sinned', God developed a
Circumstantial Will; yet God would prevail in the end with God's Ultimate Will. This model was helpful in showing the complexity in the use of the term "God's Will," but it does not solve the problem of evil.
More recently, the esteemed New Testament scholar, Bart Erhman, and professor of religion at the University of North Carolina, published a book entitled God's Problem. I have not yet read the book, which discusses the problem why an all-powerful God allows human suffering. It is my understanding that after dealing with the contradictory biblical explanations, he arrives at atheism, which is, as Rami points out, one possible logical conclusion to the problem of evil.
In 1949, my sister Betsy was born with cystic fibrosis, and died in 1951 when I was 4 years old, The 'theology' of my parents' fundamentalist Baptist church, simply labelled her life and death as "God's will," and I was "comforted" with the pronouncement that she was "too good for this world!" and that Jesus took her to be in heaven. Years later, I realized that even at age 4, I was able to question this (to myself) and come to the conclusion that I was bad enough to stay around. I guess this was my introduction to what psychologists call cognitive dissonance. I want to believe that there is a cosmic life force and energy that is Light and Love, and that the "Holy Mystery" is stronger than evil. But so often it seems that evil is winning.
Tuesday, October 9, 2012
Searching for Community: "Cheers"
A few years back, I identified myself in a letter to the editor of a state Baptist journal as:
"a liberal ex-Baptist contrarian heretic."
Actually, I despise labels.
As the great Syracuse University educator Sol Gordon said:
"To label is to disable."
But I probably fall somewhere on the broad spectrum of "Christian" ('fall' being the operative word.)
That being said, I realize that my spirituality is not simply a solitary matter.
No one is responsible for my spirituality but me; but I need the support of others on this journey.
I have that support in Janice, my life's partner...and she in me.
But we both need more.
Over my lifetime, I've been a member of 8 different Baptist churches, two Congregational churches, and one Unitarian Universalist fellowship. Of those, I've served on the staff of 6.
But the spiritual community I seek I have only found sporadically in small groups...and the old denominational labels were irrelevant. What was relevant was mutual acceptance and support.
So, for better or worse, the best picture of the community that I seek can best be described by the theme song for ...
wait for it...
the classic tv sit-com about a bar in Boston titled "Cheers:"
Making your way in the world today
takes everything you've got.
Taking a break from all your worries
sure would help a lot.
Wouldn't you like to get away?
Sometimes you want to go
Where everybody knows your name.
And they're always glad you came.
You wanna be where you can see
our troubles are all the same.
You wanna be where everybody knows your name.
"a liberal ex-Baptist contrarian heretic."
Actually, I despise labels.
As the great Syracuse University educator Sol Gordon said:
"To label is to disable."
But I probably fall somewhere on the broad spectrum of "Christian" ('fall' being the operative word.)
That being said, I realize that my spirituality is not simply a solitary matter.
No one is responsible for my spirituality but me; but I need the support of others on this journey.
I have that support in Janice, my life's partner...and she in me.
But we both need more.
Over my lifetime, I've been a member of 8 different Baptist churches, two Congregational churches, and one Unitarian Universalist fellowship. Of those, I've served on the staff of 6.
But the spiritual community I seek I have only found sporadically in small groups...and the old denominational labels were irrelevant. What was relevant was mutual acceptance and support.
So, for better or worse, the best picture of the community that I seek can best be described by the theme song for ...
wait for it...
the classic tv sit-com about a bar in Boston titled "Cheers:"
Making your way in the world today
takes everything you've got.
Taking a break from all your worries
sure would help a lot.
Wouldn't you like to get away?
Sometimes you want to go
Where everybody knows your name.
And they're always glad you came.
You wanna be where you can see
our troubles are all the same.
You wanna be where everybody knows your name.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)